Premier Protein Best Flavors: All Ranked!

Want to know which ones are Premier Protein Best Flavors? In this post we rank them all so you know which ones to get (and to skip!).

Whether you’re a dedicated fitness enthusiast or someone who values a well-rounded diet, protein supplements offer a convenient solution to meet your body’s nutritional requirements. When finding a brand that excels in quality and taste, look no further than Premier Protein.

Renowned for its signature protein shakes, Premier Protein delivers a substantial protein boost without the unnecessary burden of excessive sugar or calories. These portable shakes are ideal for maintaining your healthy routine, whether constantly moving or simply leading a busy lifestyle.

Jump to:

• Strawberries & Cream
• Peaches & Cream
• Pumpkin Spice
• Oats & Maple
• Cake Batter Delight
• Blueberries & Cream with Oats
• Vanilla
• Bananas & Cream
• Cinnamon Roll
• Cookies & Cream
• Caramel
• Chocolate Peanut Butter
• Chocolate
• Café Latte
• Frequently asked questions about Premier protein’s best flavors

However, it’s important to note that not all flavors are created equal. To assist you in making an informed decision, we present our definitive ranking of the finest Premier Protein flavors that deserve a spot in your shopping cart.

Strawberries & Cream

For those who relish the experience of indulging in the residual milk from a delicious bowl of sugary cereal, the Strawberries & Cream shake flavor offers a healthier alternative.

It captures the essence of that familiar combination, albeit with a subtly artificial touch. However, this flavor is at the lower end of our ranking of the absolute best choices due to personal preferences.

Peaches & Cream

Who can resist the allure of a perfectly ripe peach? While peaches may have a more subtle taste than other fruits, their simplicity and natural sweetness make them incredibly versatile in various culinary creations.

The fruit shines in countless dishes, from pies and cobblers to the classic combination of baked peaches and vanilla ice cream. Peaches are often featured in delightful forms like iced tea or smoothies, even as a beverage flavor.

Undoubtedly, peach is an underappreciated flavor that those who genuinely appreciate it know to be delicious when infused into drinks. However, Premier Protein’s attempt to capture the essence of peaches and cream falls short, leaving us disappointed and unsatisfied in our quest for that perfect peach-craving fix.

The Peaches & Cream protein shake from the brand carries an artificial taste that fails to resemble the natural flavor of peaches if it does so. Peaches have a milder taste, which may pose challenges translating them into shake form.

We hoped this creamy beverage would exude more authentic peach flavor rather than resembling off-tasting milk. While a few may find this drink acceptable, among all the Premier Protein flavors available, it’s doubtful that many protein shake enthusiasts would claim Peaches & Cream as their favorite.

Pumpkin Spice

Think the delightful taste of pumpkin spice is limited to your beloved coffee chains? Think again because Premier Protein has ingeniously crafted a protein shake version that captures the essence of this seasonal favorite.

Savor the comforting sense of a slice of pumpkin pie without experiencing the subsequent sugar crash. However, due to its richer profile, this flavor is best enjoyed on occasional indulgences rather than an everyday choice, so it didn’t secure a higher position on our list.

Oats & Maple

Imagine a leisurely weekend brunch where you indulge in hot, buttery pancakes. They’re light, fluffy, and nearly impossible to resist. And what better way to crown this breakfast delight than with a generous drizzle of sweet maple syrup?

As per Massmaple.org, maple syrup is carefully crafted by extracting the sap from sugar maple trees and skillfully concentrating its natural sweetness. This liquid gold is the perfect accompaniment for pancakes and a myriad of culinary creations. However, Premier Protein’s Oats & Maple shake fails to capture the essence that maple syrup lovers would expect.

Regrettably, Premier Protein’s Oats & Maple shake doesn’t deliver a creamy maple syrup-flavored experience but an unpleasant medicinal aftertaste. Its excessive sweetness feels artificial, and the maple flavor falls short of resembling genuine maple. While we certainly don’t recommend consuming a cup of maple syrup for health reasons, it’s safe to say that it would likely taste better than this drink.

Adding to the disappointment, the shake contains only 20 grams of protein, 10 grams less than most of Premier Protein’s other offerings. If there’s one protein shake from this brand we suggest avoiding, it’s Oats & Maple.

Cake Batter Delight

If the irresistible allure of cake batter always leads you to fill up your cup at the local frozen yogurt spot, then Premier Protein’s Cake Batter Delight flavor is tailor-made for you. It boasts a delightful sweetness that captures the essence of a delectable cake adorned with luscious frosting.

However, it leans towards the sweeter side, which might not appeal to those who prefer more sophisticated flavors. Consequently, it secures the eighth spot on our list.

Blueberries & Cream with Oats

When envisioning a satisfying breakfast, images of creamy oatmeal or a luscious parfait often come to mind, complete with a generous serving of fresh and juicy blueberries. These versatile little berries elevate any culinary creation, from pastries to the classic indulgence of blueberry pancakes.

Blueberries, with their delightful flavor and vibrant hue, have an impressive range of uses. Whether enjoyed dried, sugared, or transformed into jams and juices, the only downside to these berries is the challenge of removing their stains from clothing after enjoying a handful.

However, when it comes to Premier Protein’s Blueberries & Cream Shake with Oats, there’s more to be said. While the intention is to replicate the taste of sweet blueberry oatmeal, the drink falls short, resulting in an odd, overly sweet cream flavor.

The blueberry presence is disappointing, as it fails to capture the essence of fresh blueberries. If served at breakfast, it might be reminiscent of an overly sweetened blueberry muffin, which isn’t necessarily unpleasant. Still, it doesn’t align with the expectations one would have for a protein shake with this flavor.

Vanilla

Regarded as a classic choice, vanilla may seem basic, but it is far from dull. Premier Protein has masterfully crafted a rendition that consistently earns its place on grocery store shelves.

This flavor resembles Cake Batter Delight, albeit with a more understated appeal. A pro tip: Incorporate it into recipes that typically call for sweet dairy products for a healthier yet equally delightful twist. Vanilla is a versatile option that guarantees satisfaction.

Bananas & Cream

While not the most commonly chosen shake flavor, bananas lend perfectly to cold beverages, whether blended into fruity smoothies or sliced atop indulgent ice cream sundaes. Even fast-food giant McDonald’s recognizes the appeal of a refreshing banana drink, with their strawberry banana smoothie being a top seller during hot summer days and even in cooler seasons.

Thanks to their high potassium content, bananas also make for a fantastic pre-or post-workout snack. If you’re craving a banana-flavored drink that provides a protein boost and delivers a range of other essential nutrients, look no further.

Premier Protein’s Bananas & Cream protein shake, as described on their official website, is a “smooth, delectable shake that helps you meet your body’s protein needs.” True to its name, this banana shake captures a creamy banana’s essence. While it may not contain as much potassium as a fresh banana, its remarkably light, creamy, and pleasantly sweet taste compensates.

The Premier Protein website even features a recipe for banana ice cream that can be made using this mightily shake and a few extra bananas. Among all the fruit-flavored protein drinks offered by the brand, this one undeniably stands out. If you’re a banana enthusiast, prepare to be delighted by this delicious protein shake.

Cinnamon Roll

Ranked highly among Premier Protein flavors, this delightful option offers the experience of indulging in your beloved breakfast treat without the subsequent heaviness.

If the idea of Pumpkin Spice appeals to you, but you seek a more balanced flavor profile, Cinnamon Roll is the perfect alternative to explore. Try it and savor the essence of a comforting cinnamon roll without the overwhelming sensation.

Cookies & Cream

Premier Protein hits the mark flawlessly when it comes to capturing the irresistible essence of cookies and cream.

Their Cookies & Cream shake is a testament to this, as it skillfully replicates the delightful taste of our cherished chocolatey, creamy cookies dipped in milk—an ideal indulgence for those seeking a satisfying afternoon treat.

Caramel

The Caramel flavor from Premier Protein is a true delight, suitable for any time of the day. It strikes the perfect balance, neither overpowering nor excessively artificial.

Enjoy it as a standalone refreshment, or use it as a protein-rich alternative to coffee creamer for an extra boost in your daily pick-me-up. Suppose you haven’t had the chance to savor this enticing flavor yet; take our word for it and grab a pack on your next visit to the store. You won’t be disappointed.

Chocolate Peanut Butter

Regarding irresistible pairings, few can compete with the timeless combination of chocolate and peanut butter. Whether it’s in the form of candies or this exceptional Premier Protein flavor, the harmonious blend is hard to resist.

Creamy, indulgent, and flawlessly balanced, this shake exudes perfection from every sip. If you’re a devoted peanut butter enthusiast, this is a flavor you cannot afford to miss.

Chocolate

You simply can’t go wrong with Chocolate when it comes to classic flavors. Premier Protein’s Chocolate flavor is a testament to this timeless appeal. It strikes the perfect balance, delivering a delectable experience without overwhelming the taste buds with excessive sweetness or intensity.

This versatile option ensures you can enjoy it anytime, anywhere, treating yourself to a delightful and indulgent blend of protein and essential vitamins. Embrace the deliciousness of Chocolate while nourishing your body with every sip.

Café Latte

Claiming the top spot on our definitive ranking of the finest Premier Protein flavors is Café Latte. While it may not cater to those who strongly dislike the taste of coffee, it is an absolute delight for everyone else.

Whether you consider yourself a discerning coffee connoisseur or simply enjoy a generous dose of creaminess in your cup, this protein shake is guaranteed to satisfy. Striking the perfect balance, it offers a harmonious blend of coffee and creamy goodness.

This refreshing drink is the ideal companion to kickstart your mornings, delivering a flavor that is neither overly sweet nor lacking in depth. Indulge in the allure of Café Latte and let it awaken your senses for a refreshing start to the day.

In conclusion, Premier Protein offers a range of flavors that cater to different tastes and preferences. While individual preferences may vary, some flavors stand out as particularly enjoyable.

The Café Latte flavor takes the top spot with its coffee and creamy goodness balance, making it a perfect morning pick-me-up. Chocolate and Chocolate Peanut Butter follow closely behind, delivering classic and decadent combinations that are hard to resist. The Vanilla flavor offers a satisfying and versatile option, perfect for incorporating into various recipes.

The remaining flavors, such as Cookies & Cream, Caramel, and Cake Batter Delight, provide indulgent and delightful experiences. However, it’s important to note that personal taste preferences play a significant role, and individuals may have different rankings based on their choices.

Ultimately, exploring the Premier Protein flavor lineup can lead to finding a favorite that satisfies protein needs and taste preferences.

Frequently asked questions about Premier protein’s best flavors