Want to know what are the best Sonic Milkshakes? In this post we rank all sonic Drive In milkshake menu options.
I took up a daunting challenge to sample every flavor to determine the best milkshake on Sonic Drive-In’s menu. Yes, you read that right I had every milkshake on their menu.
The drive-in staff met my order with shock and amusement; I guess it’s not every day someone wants one of everything.
Whether this ambitious undertaking would evoke joy or regret remained unknown – but one thing was sure: it promised a big surprise!
My mission? To rank them all!
With plenty of smiles (and napkins!), the team served a delicious array of milkshakes for my enjoyment.
The Golden Girls may never have had the chance to experience a Sonic Drive-In fully, but one can only imagine that this tantalizing shake would be near the top of their list.
While Rose no doubt would have regaled them with stories about St. Olaf’s very own cow named “Sonic,” and Blanche probably charmed someone in an adjacent vehicle into giving her his number, nothing could compare to how joyful they’d feel after sampling this delicious treat!
Sonic’s “Cheesecake” shake may be prepared quickly, but the taste leaves something to be desired.
An unlikely combination of sugar and cream with a hint of lemon makes this milkshake unlike any cheesecake we’ve ever had; however, it is far from bland, and one wouldn’t likely find themselves enjoying its flavor around the dinner table.
Sonic’s caramel shake may be a classic favorite, but if you’re searching for flavor and decadence – this isn’t the milkshake for you.
The sweet distinction between its cold drinkability and vanilla counterpart is not one to savor — with no more than a hint of rich complexity present within its creamy depths.
A can of diet soda provides greater satisfaction when tasting something genuinely indulgent.
If you’re looking for something sweet with a hint of burnt sugar, skip over Sonic’s caramel shake.
Its weak flavoring fails to yield any authentic caramel taste and leaves behind an uninteresting vanilla ice cream – indeed, not worth the price point tbh.
Those searching for crème Brulee or Snickers flavors should turn elsewhere on their menu; there are more options available, all certain to be considerably tastier than its lackluster iteration of ‘caramel’ shakes.
Sonic sugar free drinks: All their sugar free options ranked
Sonic’s espresso milkshake could be an ideal option if you’re a coffee connoisseur and looking for your next indulgent treat.
Despite closely resembling Starbucks’ Frappuccino appearance, this frozen beverage’s flavor is much more creamy and sweet than it is caffeinated – with each mini shake achieving over 400 calories!
Sonic’s Espresso Shake provides a distinctively robust and well-rounded coffee flavor – ideal for caffeine connoisseurs.
While the deep, bold taste may pair more suitably with other dishes than those typically served at Sonic restaurants such as chicken strips, fries, and hamburgers, it is definitely worth ordering (and savoring) solo if you enjoy its distinctive blend of java notes.
Despite its claims of chocolaty deliciousness, Sonic’s chocolate shake fails to deliver.
Upon taking the first sip, you may be taken aback by a flavor that falls short of cocoa-like sweetness and leaves much to be desired – even in contention with Summer’s balmy air; it remains watery and unappealing.
It’s like frozen Ovaltine – not quite milky chocolate or deep and decadent mousse, it offers something different for your palette!
If you’re craving rich fudge flavor or famous Oreo chunks, there are other options so keep reading.
Experience an intriguing combination of flavors with the Sonic menu’s Oreo Espresso.
The perfect blend will tantalize your taste buds as you get a creamy and smooth sip delicately nuanced by subtle notes of espresso and Oreo crumbles – no aggressive flavor explosion here!
Sonic’s Oreo Espresso shake could be a hit-or-miss experience, depending on your taste. My recommendation? If you’re a fan of the sugary sweetness of Oreos or the robust flavor of espresso, opt for one individually rather than trying to have both in one cup.
Sonic’s banana shake is a treat like none other, packing an intense punch due to its thickness courtesy of the real bananas used in making it.
A force to be reckoned with, this milkshake commands attention thanks not only to its heaviness but also to being rife with both ice cream and sugar – so make sure you warm up your sucking muscles before tackling this challenge!
Sonic’s Banana Shake provides a cooling, light taste to brighten any summer meal.
While the flavor may be fleeting and not relatively as fresh, it has just enough banana flavoring to offer an enjoyable experience with your favorite burger and fries combinations.
To ensure you get all of this shake’s sublime refreshment, we recommend eating it rather than sipping — or preparing for unexpected brain freeze while sitting in your car!
Sonic’s hot fudge shake evokes a warm nostalgia with each sip. It is reminiscent of childhood memories spent at state fairs, enjoying hand-dipped ice cream cones and leaving behind a trail chocolatey mess.
This milkshake captures those moments perfectly, allowing one to savor the flavor of summertime no matter what season it may be outside.
While memories of Sonic’s hot fudge milkshake may evoke nostalgia from days gone by, its taste as an adult likely won’t stand up to expectations.
The sugary sweetness it brings with the first sip is fleeting; when all is said and done, you’ll be left wanting more out of this classic treat.
Fortunately for chocolate connoisseurs, there are plenty more options on the menu that will satisfy a grown-up palette!
Far from a bland flavor deserving of its usual bad rap, Vanilla is the favorite ice cream choice for 15 percent of people.
Even when it comes to Sonic shakes, Vanilla makes quite an impression outranking all other flavors except chocolate – proving why this timeless classic will always remain at the top!
This famous vanilla milkshake flaunts a thick, creamy consistency with sweet notes that even evoke an undertone of custard.
Despite its traditional flavor profile and lack of novelty, it continues to fill the palates of many customers thanks to its delicious take on classic flavors. Simple yet effective!
Sonic’s original strawberry milkshake delivers the classic flavor profile, while its cheesecakey counterpart provides a richer and more indulgent experience.
Sonic’s strawberry cheesecake shake is the perfect balance of rich and sweet if you’re looking for a decadent treat after an indulgence-free dinner. Crafted with expert precision to deliver an enjoyable flavor profile, it’s best enjoyed on an empty stomach – so be sure to only fill up after trying this delicious delight!
Sonic Drive-In’s Oreo milkshake offers a classic flavor that never fails to satisfy.
Famed for its beloved ingredients, the cookie leverages its famous branding across each delicious sip of this sweet treat – making it America’s favorite drive-in shake!
If you are a fan of cookies and cream ice cream, then the Oreo shake is sure to delight you.
This indulgent combination of sugar and chocolate will satisfy your sweet tooth like no other. Although we wouldn’t recommend having it as lunch on its own, feel free to experiment with combing this flavor with any others available to explore even more taste sensations!
Enjoy the nostalgia of a classic childhood treat with Sonic’s strawberry shake.
This milkshake offers an elevated experience, starting with a creamy and artificially sweet flavor before providing subtle hints of natural fruit to tantalize your taste buds.
Sonic’s strawberry shake has a light and natural flavor, combining the sweetness of frozen strawberries with their signature flavoring.
Carefully blended for an enjoyable textural experience – not too strong, but enough to tell you’re drinking something special! Better than many other competitors, it will surely leave you refreshed after every sip.
With an unreal thickness that rivals the banana shake, Sonic’s peanut butter shake will undoubtedly give you more than your money’s worth.
Unsurprisingly, this shake contains a thick and sweet concoction reminiscent of the iconic Butterfinger bar.
Those who long for classic sugary peanut butter snacks from childhood will revel in their taste. However, those seeking more natural varieties may want to steer clear; nothing resembles traditional nuttiness here – just pure sweetness!
Refined and indulgent, Sonic’s Oreo Cheesecake milkshake is an utterly delicious treat.
Though it packs enough calories to power a junior high track team, the mini size provides just as much flavor without the same guilt – making this delectable beverage no less than Rick Astley’s shakes!
Sonic’s cheesecake flavor is euphoric, captivating the tongue and mind with its intense palette.
Then comes an unmistakable hint of Oreo to bring all that pleasure into balance before it concludes on a mysterious caramel note – concluding in pure bliss. Sonic truly hit this one out of the park; be sure you’re composed before leaving once your experience has ended!
Oreo peanut butter
Sonic has crafted the perfect solution for those overwhelmed by too many delicious options at the checkout. Combining two of America’s favorite treats – Oreo cookies and peanut butter cups- Sonic has created an irresistible milkshake that will leave you wondering why this combination didn’t exist before!
Savour the divine combination of Reese’s peanut butter and Oreo cookie flavor in Sonic’s indulgent signature shake. This rich blend consists of ice cream, Vanilla with a sprinkle of ‘pixie dust’ to elevate it from good to great! Perfect for those seeking an intense taste sensation: brace yourself; each sip will deliver overwhelming levels of sweetness coated by thick pockets of creamy peanut butter. Be warned – this shake may require utensils due to its extreme thickness!